The Commercial Bid Evaluation document serves as a critical tool in Indonesian procurement processes, designed to facilitate objective and transparent assessment of commercial proposals. It is primarily used when organizations need to evaluate multiple bids for goods, services, or works, ensuring compliance with Indonesian procurement laws, particularly Presidential Regulation No. 16 of 2018 and related procurement guidelines. The document encompasses comprehensive evaluation criteria including technical capabilities, financial proposals, compliance requirements, and risk assessments. It provides a structured methodology for comparing and scoring bids, documenting the evaluation process, and supporting the final selection decision. This evaluation framework is essential for both public and private sector procurement activities in Indonesia, helping organizations demonstrate due diligence and maintain audit trails of their procurement decisions.
Your data doesn't train Genie's AI
You keep IP ownership of your information
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
OR
Let Ƶ's market-leading legal AI identify missing terms, unusual language, compliance issues and more - in just seconds.
1. Executive Summary: Brief overview of the evaluation process, key findings, and recommendations
2. Introduction: Context of the procurement, reference to tender documents, and evaluation objectives
3. Evaluation Methodology: Detailed explanation of evaluation approach, scoring system, and weightage criteria
4. Bidder Overview: List of participating bidders and confirmation of bid submission compliance
5. Technical Evaluation: Detailed assessment of technical proposals against specified criteria
6. Financial Evaluation: Analysis of commercial proposals, price comparisons, and financial viability assessment
7. Compliance Assessment: Evaluation of legal and regulatory compliance, including required certifications and documentation
8. Risk Assessment: Analysis of potential risks associated with each bid
9. Comparative Analysis: Side-by-side comparison of bids across all evaluation criteria
10. Conclusions and Recommendations: Final scoring, ranking, and recommendations for award
1. Local Content Evaluation: Assessment of local content requirements and compliance - used when local content rules apply
2. Environmental Impact Assessment: Evaluation of environmental considerations - used for projects with environmental implications
3. Social Impact Evaluation: Assessment of social and community impact - used for projects affecting local communities
4. Innovation Assessment: Evaluation of innovative solutions or technologies - used when innovation is a key criterion
5. Past Performance Analysis: Detailed review of bidders' track record - used for high-value or critical projects
6. Capacity Assessment: Evaluation of bidders' resource and capacity capabilities - used for large-scale projects
1. Technical Scoring Matrix: Detailed scoring sheets for technical evaluation criteria
2. Financial Comparison Tables: Detailed price breakdowns and financial comparisons
3. Compliance Checklist: Checklist of all required documents and certifications
4. Technical Specifications: Original technical specifications against which bids were evaluated
5. Evaluation Team Composition: List of evaluators and their qualifications
6. Bid Clarification Records: Documentation of any clarifications requested and received during evaluation
7. Risk Assessment Matrix: Detailed risk evaluation matrices for each bid
8. Evaluation Timeline: Timeline of the evaluation process and key milestones
Relevant legal definitions
Clauses
Relevant Industries
Infrastructure
Energy
Mining
Manufacturing
Technology
Healthcare
Transportation
Construction
Telecommunications
Public Services
Oil and Gas
Education
Financial Services
Utilities
Agriculture
Relevant Teams
Procurement
Legal
Finance
Technical Assessment
Risk Management
Compliance
Operations
Supply Chain
Commercial Operations
Project Management
Internal Audit
Quality Assurance
Relevant Roles
Procurement Manager
Bid Evaluation Specialist
Technical Director
Financial Analyst
Legal Counsel
Project Manager
Commercial Director
Compliance Officer
Risk Manager
Contract Administrator
Chief Financial Officer
Operations Director
Supply Chain Manager
Procurement Specialist
Technical Evaluator
Find the exact document you need
Peer To Peer Feedback
An Indonesian law-compliant framework for structured peer-to-peer feedback processes, aligned with local labor and data protection regulations.
Download
Job Appraisal Letter
An Indonesian-compliant formal document recording employee performance evaluation results, aligned with Law No. 13/2003 on Manpower.
Download
360 Appraisal Form
An Indonesian law-compliant 360-degree performance evaluation form for comprehensive employee assessment from multiple stakeholders.
Download
Volunteer Performance Evaluation
An Indonesian-compliant framework for evaluating volunteer performance and impact, aligned with local regulations and cultural considerations.
Download
Seminar Feedback Form
An Indonesian-compliant feedback collection form for seminar evaluation, designed to gather participant insights while adhering to local data protection regulations.
Download
Food Evaluation
An Indonesian-compliant agreement for professional food evaluation services, including testing, analysis, and regulatory compliance requirements.
Download
Probationary Employee Performance Evaluation Form
An Indonesian-law compliant performance evaluation form for assessing employees during their probationary period.
Download
90 Day Evaluation
An Indonesian law-compliant agreement establishing a 90-day evaluation period for new employees, outlining terms, conditions, and assessment criteria.
Download
Basic Appraisal Form
A standardized employee performance evaluation form compliant with Indonesian labor laws, designed for comprehensive assessment and development planning.
Download
Appraisal Form Filled By Employees
A comprehensive employee performance evaluation form compliant with Indonesian labor laws, designed for structured assessment and development planning.
Download
Pitching Evaluation Form
A standardized form for evaluating business pitches in Indonesia, ensuring compliance with local business laws while maintaining objectivity and transparency.
Download
Performance Evaluation For Managers
A legally compliant framework for managerial performance evaluation in Indonesia, aligned with Law No. 13/2003 on Manpower and related regulations.
Download
Bonus Evaluation
An Indonesian law-compliant document outlining the framework and criteria for employee bonus evaluation and determination.
Download
Website Evaluation
An Indonesian law-governed agreement for professional website evaluation services, defining evaluation scope, methodology, and deliverables while ensuring regulatory compliance.
Download
Skills Evaluation
An Indonesian law-compliant document establishing the framework and procedures for professional skills evaluation, aligned with BNSP standards.
Download
Probation Appraisal Form
An Indonesian law-compliant evaluation form for assessing employee performance during probationary periods, structured according to Law No. 13 of 2003 on Manpower.
Download
Teacher Appraisal
A comprehensive teacher evaluation framework aligned with Indonesian education laws, outlining appraisal procedures and competency assessment criteria.
Download
Service Evaluation
An Indonesian law-governed agreement establishing terms and framework for professional service evaluation, including methodology, criteria, and reporting requirements.
Download
Evaluation Form
An Indonesian law-compliant employee evaluation form for structured performance assessment and development planning.
Download
Employee Annual Review
An Indonesian law-compliant annual employee performance evaluation document for structured assessment and development planning.
Download
30 60 90 Day Evaluation
An Indonesian law-compliant 30-60-90 day employee evaluation agreement establishing performance metrics and assessment procedures.
Download
Website Evaluation Form
An Indonesian-compliant Website Evaluation Form for comprehensive assessment of website functionality, user experience, and regulatory compliance under Indonesian law.
Download
Teacher Evaluation
A comprehensive teacher evaluation framework compliant with Indonesian education laws and regulations, designed for use in both public and private educational institutions.
Download
Team Evaluation Form
A standardized employee evaluation form compliant with Indonesian labor laws, designed for comprehensive performance assessment and development planning.
Download
Performance Appraisal
An Indonesian law-compliant performance appraisal template for systematic employee evaluation and development planning.
Download
Presentation Skills Evaluation Form
A comprehensive presentation skills assessment tool compliant with Indonesian labor laws and workplace evaluation standards.
Download
Performance Evaluation Form For Managers
An Indonesian law-compliant performance evaluation form for assessing managerial effectiveness, goal achievement, and leadership competencies.
Download
Team Feedback Form
An Indonesian law-compliant employee evaluation document for structured performance feedback and development planning.
Download
Employee Self Evaluation Form
An Indonesian law-compliant Employee Self Evaluation Form for structured self-assessment of performance, achievements, and development needs.
Download
Probationary Assessment Form
An Indonesian-compliant performance evaluation form used to assess employees during their statutory maximum three-month probationary period.
Download
Department Evaluation
An Indonesian-compliant document for conducting systematic departmental performance and efficiency evaluations under local labor laws and regulations.
Download
Construction Project Evaluation
An Indonesian law-compliant document for evaluating construction projects' compliance, progress, and quality against regulatory and project requirements.
Download
Commercial Bid Evaluation
An Indonesian-compliant document for systematic evaluation and comparison of commercial bids, following local procurement regulations and best practices.
Download
Waiter Performance Evaluation Form
An Indonesian law-compliant performance evaluation form for wait staff, assessing service quality and professional standards in hospitality settings.
Download
Leadership Evaluation
An Indonesian law-compliant leadership evaluation framework for assessing and developing organizational leaders' capabilities and performance.
Download
Webinar Evaluation Form
An Indonesian law-compliant webinar feedback collection form that evaluates session quality, content, and delivery while ensuring data protection.
Download
Performance Feedback Form
An Indonesian law-compliant performance evaluation document for structured employee assessment and feedback documentation.
Download
Sales Performance Evaluation
An Indonesian law-compliant framework for evaluating sales performance, including metrics and review procedures aligned with local labor regulations.
Download
Project Feedback
An Indonesian law-compliant document for formal project performance evaluation and feedback, structured according to local labor and data protection regulations.
Download
Manager Appraisal Form
A comprehensive manager performance evaluation tool compliant with Indonesian labor laws and regulations.
Download
ұԾ’s Security Promise
Genie is the safest place to draft. Here’s how we prioritise your privacy and security.
Your documents are private:
We do not train on your data; ұԾ’s AI improves independently
All data stored on Genie is private to your organisation
Your documents are protected:
Your documents are protected by ultra-secure 256-bit encryption
We are ISO27001 certified, so your data is secure
Organizational security:
You retain IP ownership of your documents and their information
You have full control over your data and who gets to see it
.png)